Some audiophiles read my articles and think I absolutely hate vinyl. I don’t at all. In fact, I have been thinking of adding a turntable to my ever-evolving living room music playback system.
The issue with vinyl is that we need to look at the nearly century-old format here from our vantage point in the 21st century. In sales, there’s a technique called “The Ben Franklin Close” where you write down the pluses and minutes on each side of a sheet of paper and evaluate the value proposition, so you can make a well-informed decision. Hell, I grew up in Philly and I never flew a kite in a thunderstorm, so perhaps I’ve made one or two good decisions? Hard to tell. Let’s try Ben’s model and see if it tells us something about the value proposition of this old analog audio format in the age of digital.
The Arguments in Favor of Vinyl in a Digital Audio Future
- We live in an overly-digital world and stress is a killer. Taking time to enjoy things that are analog, like reading an actual book or spinning an LP, has value. Turning off the blue light from your computer or the ever-present lure of social media connectivity can be a very good thing. In fact, disconnecting from our devices and listening to some fantastic music can lower your blood pressure and anxiety levels.
- Listening to a classic album on the format that it was released on and originally mastered for also has its benefits. Enjoying a record with the song order that the engineer, producer, and artist originally intended can also be appealing. Have you ever tried listening to Pink Floyd’s The Wall on shuffle? Take it from me and skip that experience. It makes no musical sense.
- Record players are a beautiful design element. They are architectural. They spin in a way that can be mesmerizing. Even a brand-new turntable packs retro appeal. A well-placed turntable can make a meaningful statement even when it isn’t spinning.
- Vinyl LPs can be an affordable way to collect old music, especially when you buy it used. Fresh pressings of 180-gram limited editions (don’t get me started on Mo-Fi) can get a little pricey, but you don’t have to go that route. My buddy Andrew and his wife love going shopping for used vinyl and classic audio gear in pawn shops in Austin, and you’ll often find racks and racks of old records at your local Goodwill.
- There is a lovely ritual when listening to vinyl that includes cleaning, spinning, and finally listening to an album. You might sit down and read the album liner notes, which promotes the calming advantages of listening to music. Does a good streaming service have more cross-referenced metadata on a record? Yes, but does that really matter when your listening experience is interrupted by a tweet from your racist aunt?
- Turntables don’t have to be crazy expensive, either. $200 buys you a pretty nice deck these days. You could spend less too and not be unhappy if you are just getting into the hobby and looking for a jumping off point. Or you could spend $500 and get a record player that would have blown the minds of your parents back in the 1980s.
The Arguments Against Vinyl in a Modern Audiophile System
- The LP as we know it has been around for a century (give or take a decade on how you want to define the format) and has terrible performance in terms of dynamic range compared to newer, digital formats. In a perfect world, vinyl could conceivably reach dynamic range levels of around 70dB. CD and high-res digital downloads or streams can reach much higher. Mind you, almost no albums are released with that much dynamic range, instead maxing out at somewhere around 30 to 40 dB for classical and avant-garde music and more like 10 to 12 dB for most rock and pop and 15 to 20 dB for better hip-hop. But with increased dynamic range comes decreased noise. You don’t want a recorded snare drum to actually hit 110 dB or you’d find your music unlistenable for the most part—that, or you’d have to ride the volume knob like an old-school studio engineer. But having more dynamic range means you push the noise floor lower and lower, and while the noise floor of today’s digital formats is inaudible, you can hear the noise in most records.
- That “warmth” that old-school audiophiles love is actually even-order harmonic distortion. When you spend your money on a world-class stereo preamp, a lot of what you are paying for is the nth degree of performance and that includes lower levels of THD (total harmonic distortion). Why feed your high-performance music system a distorted signal when you invested so much money to get electronics that are, in effect, distortion free.
- The value of today’s vinyl is poor in comparison to what it costs to have access to entire libraries of music in CD resolution of higher via streaming. The likelihood is that you already have some access to streaming music in CD/HD resolutions. Amazon Music, Qobuz, Tidal, Spotify, Pandora, Apple—so many others are either bundled in with your other technology or available for $10 to $15 per month. Oh, and you likely don’t need fancy source components to stream them into a modern audiophile system. Any number of today’s disc players are worthy streamers. Then there are dedicated streaming devices like Roku, Apple TV, Sonos, and others that offer even more compelling content while outputting killer sound. Compare those low hardware costs to new vinyl and a respectable turntable and you can see digital music has it all over analog these days.
- Large vinyl collections are heavy and unwieldy. I know of a number of music collectors who simply ran out of room to store any more LPs so they had to start selling off music that they aren’t likely to listen to much in the future. Digital music storage takes up little to no space. Legally ripping your Compact Discs is easy and you can store in the neighborhood of 25,000 albums on a 1 TB thumb drive that literally fits in your pocket and might weigh one ounce.
So How Do I Make Sense of All This Vinyl vs. Digital Hype?
Despite all the cons, there is a place for both analog and digital in most modern audiophile rigs.
Imagine you got the chance to drive around in an original-condition Mercedes 300 SL Gullwing from 1957. That would, to say the least, be a pretty cool experience, right? The patina of the paint of the Benz is awesome and could win you a Concours d’Elegance for originality—just ask Wayne Carini from Chasing Classic Cars. The tone of the exhaust on the vintage SL is intoxicating. Just looking at the curves in the metal work on such an iconic automobile is over-the-top amazing. The 60-plus years of wear on the custom-made leather luggage just adds to the fun factor of traveling in this fantastic ride. The 300 SL Gullwing is like vinyl in that it is vintage, iconic, architectural and a whole lot of bad-ass.
Now imagine getting to drive a 2023 AMG SL 63 Roadster for a while. That car today is about $178,000 at retail, which is likely one fifth of what a vintage SL will cost you at auction or private sale. The new SL does 0-to-60 in 3.5 seconds thanks to a 577 HP twin-turbo-charged V8 with 590 foot-pounds of torque. The new SL has an automated convertible hard top. It has “launch mode” in case you need to go really fast. It has steel frame crumple zones, lane change software, ABS brakes, air-conditioned seats, automatic breaking, GPS with traffic, satellite radio… and the list goes on.
In a perfect world, you might want to own both cars. I sure want to.
My issue with vinyl is how the print magazine “Elders” sell people on the concept that in a drag race, the 1957 Benz is somehow going to beat the 2023 AMG SL 63. It isn’t. It never will. But there are those in the hobby who will sell you on their kooky beliefs that a turntable will outperform hi-resolution digital. Please ignore them and follow the science. But at the same time, embrace the fact that the audiophile hobby isn’t always about objective measures of performance.
Don’t let anybody poo-poo your turntable or your vinyl collection. At the same time, don’t let anybody tell you that you are getting the closer-to-the-master performance from vinyl versus today’s digital files.
Understanding the benefits of digital audio and retro-analog is key to building a system that is right for you and the way you want your AV system to work. Traditional audiophiles won’t put a TV between their speakers because it might reflect a little sound, but they are missing out on a more complete viewing and listening experience. The old way of doing things isn’t better just because that’s the way the elders did it. Find what works for you and run with it. Screw anybody that doesn’t get it. If you want to chill while spinning Electric Ladyland from the UK import (I have one of these NSFW editions) while reading the liner notes and sipping on some small batch bourbon, who is to say you aren’t living your best life? If, the next night, you are streaming The Jimi Hendrix Experience Live From Maui from 1968 via Amazon Music HD and reading the metadata on your audio system’s dedicated iPad, you’re also enjoying an experience worth having.
Don’t let others dictate how you want your audio system to look, sound, or feel. Find what’s right for you. The audiophile journey is what the hobby is all about and you get to dictate what path you take. My hope is that you understand the advantages and disadvantages of both formats so that you make the best decisions for you. Get experienced.